The appellate court allowed the Competition Commission’s appeal and increased Prudential Hotel’s fine from HK$104,000 to HK$950,000. It also ordered the hotel to pay the costs of the appeal and the earlier tribunal hearing.
The original fine followed a Competition Tribunal finding that the hotel had breached the Competition Ordinance in a 2016 price-fixing case involving tourist attraction and transport tickets sold at hotels. The Competition Commission said hotels including Prudential acted as facilitators, passing price information between competing tourism-service providers and helping implement the arrangement.
The appellate court said the original fine did not reflect the seriousness of the hotel’s conduct or provide enough targeted or general deterrence. Because the hotel was not active in the market for the tickets, the court accepted that the Commission could depart from its usual penalty-calculation approach and use fines imposed on other participants as a reference.