A Development Bureau investigation into problems affecting all 28 lifts at Queen Mary Hospital’s Clinical Building 1 identified technical causes of frequent breakdowns and shortcomings in oversight.

The report listed four main causes of frequent breakdowns, including deviations in lift-shaft wall dimensions and verticality. It also said Architectural Services Department personnel failed to notice that a lift shaft had been chiselled without authorisation.

Clinical Building 1 began opening in phases in November 2025. The government released the investigation report the previous week.

The chair of the Legislative Council’s Development Panel said the report indicated that monitoring staff had seen problems but failed to follow them up, with changes made only at the last moment. A senior electrical and building-services engineer said the issue was how supervision was carried out, despite oversight involving the Architectural Services Department, Buildings Department and Electrical and Mechanical Services Department. He called for a review and proposed that government staff inspect work on site rather than rely only on documents.

A legislator urged authorities to examine individual participation in supervision, questioning how subsequent steps and lift permits could be approved despite numerous shortcomings and missing signatures. She also said the government should consider a civil claim against the contractor for the lifts’ long-term maintenance costs.